Work Text:
Jack had always been the kind of man who looked for patterns, for meaning in the meaningless. But after Robby, it became an obsession.
A star streaking across the sky the night they first kissed. When they finally escaped the Pitt and stole a weekend for themselves. A cabin, quiet woods, the clean, air and hush of nature. A shooting star the moment Robby’s mouth touched his, a coincidence too perfect to ignore. Jack told himself it meant something, that the universe had drawn its finger across the sky just for them. Even now, when he closed his eyes, he could see Robby against the dark and feel the sharp pull of gravity that wasn’t in the stars at all but in the way he touched him.
The thing was, Robby had wanted it first.
He was the one who closed the space between them that night, daring and grinning and saying, You can’t pretend you don’t feel this too. He was the one who had nudged Jack into dates, slipping him a coffee with his order scrawled in messy Sharpie across the lid, the lingering touches on the roof before handoff. Robby dragging him to the late-night diner two blocks from the hospital, convincing him to drive out to a little dive bar where no one knew their names. It had been Robby who made it easy, who carved out pieces of ordinary life for them between the blood and sirens. Robby who had turned their stolen time into something that felt like a future.
Jack hadn’t known he wanted any of it until Robby gave it to him.
And then, just as suddenly, Robby ripped the rug out from under him. No fight. No warning. No reason. Just silence.
cold
clean
devastating silence.
Jack had begged him, not out loud but in the thousand ways he kept reaching after. A hand that lingered too long. An offer to grab dinner. A question left hanging in the space between them. Robby never picked them up. He just looked away.
Jack told himself he couldn’t let that be coincidence either...that the universe wouldn’t play him like that. But the truth was harder, crueler. He carried the silence like a stone in his chest, drowning under its weight.
Even now, when the hospital hallways were quiet and the world pressed down with exhaustion, he caught himself watching the clock at 11:11. Folding his arms, shutting his eyes, making a wish he pretended wasn’t always the same.
He kept pretending he’d moved on. Pretending the signs meant nothing, that he didn’t still find himself waiting for the clock to flip to 11:11 like some lovesick teenager.
On the nights he missed it...when time slipped past too quickly...he carried the disappointment like a bruise, the rest of the night off-kilter, hollow. It was a ritual now, no matter how much he wished it wasn’t. And still, every broken wishbone, every spilled pinch of salt, every crack in the pavement dragged him back, every superstition looping the same cruel circle. Always to him. Always to them.
Jack told himself he didn’t believe in signs anymore. Or at least, he tried to. Easier that way, easier than admitting he still searched for them in the smallest things. He told himself the night sky, the clocks, the coincidences meant nothing. But that was a lie, and he knew it. Because every time the monitor above the nurses’ station blinked 11:11, he caught himself making the same damn wish all over again.
And then Robby’s voice would carry down the ER hallway like it was meant for him alone.
It was muscle memory now, the way their bodies moved in sync across the trauma bay. One reached, the other passed. One ordered, the other answered. Seamless, mechanical, carved into their bones. Everyone else saw efficiency. Jack saw survival. He felt the knife twist every time Robby met his eyes and then looked away too quickly, as though even that glance was dangerous.
Jack knew better. He knew what it cost to keep that rhythm alive.
Because every brush of a sleeve, every half-second of eye contact, every time Robby said his name, the wish came back. The one he couldn’t kill. The one that dragged him under.
They worked side by side as if nothing had happened, as if nothing had been torn out of Jack’s chest and left to bleed. He hated himself for it. Hated that he still remembered the way Robby’s laugh sounded muffled against his neck.
He hated Robby for it, too. For the way he could slip back into normalcy, as if those battered black New Balances hadn’t once been left on the floor of Jack’s bedroom in a careless heap beside tangled clothes. They should have been meaningless. Instead, every time Jack saw them scuffing the linoleum, he thought about Robby pulling them on in the morning, hair damp, grin soft, their whole damn future spread out ahead of them.
And then came the whispers. Little bits of gossip among the nurses: Robby was seeing someone new.
The first time, it threw Jack. By the time Dana mentioned it casually at handoff, he hadn’t flinched. He’d smiled, nodded, said something dry and dismissive. Later, alone in his apartment, he lay staring at the ceiling, trying not to picture it, Robby holding someone else’s hand, kissing them under a city sky that didn’t belong to Jack. He told himself it was fine. Better this way. Robby deserved someone uncomplicated. Someone who wasn’t a mess of jagged edges and silence.
But the bitterness rotted him. Forgetting meant silence, and silence meant suffocating under the weight of everything unsaid. The dangerous truth was he hadn’t stopped wanting.
When salt spilled across the break room counter, he still tossed it over his shoulder and wished. Every time he saw the little black cat outside wandering around his apartment, he paused, holding his breath until it disappeared…and glee set a can of food outside his door. When he stepped across a cracked sidewalk outside the hospital, his chest still tightened like it was an omen.
He wanted to bury it deep. To shake it off. But then Robby would laugh...too loud...too bright...and Jack would remember that night under the falling star, when he had believed, truly believed, that the universe had set them on a path together.
Now every glance, every shift, every moment was a punishment.
And still, at 11:11, Jack wished. He wished in spite of himself, knowing full well the cruelty of it.
Because the worst part wasn’t that Robby was gone.
The worst part was that he wasn’t gone at all. He was right there, every single day, close enough to touch...already lost.