Archive of Our Own

Recent bookmarks

1. Public Bookmark 47

   They never existed| Creepypasta x reader by Natsukiisimp

   Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom  

   • General Audiences
   • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
   • F/F
   • Work in Progress

   05 May 2026

   Tags

   • Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
   • Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers | Ticci Toby/Reader
   • Jeffrey Woods | Jeff the Killer/Reader
   • Liu Woods | Homicidal Liu/Reader
   • Eyeless Jack/Reader
   • Laughing Jack/Reader
   • Ben (BEN Drowned)/Reader
   • Jane Arkensaw | Jane the Killer/Reader
   • Helen Otis | The Bloody Painter/Reader
   • Timothy "Tim" Wright | Masky/You
   • Brian Thomas | Hoody/Reader
   • Kagekao (Creepypasta)/Reader
   • Natalie Ouellette | Clockwork/Reader
   • Jonathan Blake | The Puppeteer/Reader
   • Jason Meyer | Jason the Toymaker/Reader
   • Zalgo (Creepypasta)/Reader
   • Zalgo (Creepypasta)/You
   • Jeffrey Woods | Jeff the Killer
   • Jane Arkensaw | Jane the Killer
   • Liu Woods | Homicidal Liu
   • Sully | Liu Woods' Alternate Personality
   • Grinny Cat
   • Slender Man
   • Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers | Ticci Toby
   • Eyeless Jack
   • Laughing Jack
   • Helen Otis | The Bloody Painter
   • Sally Williams (Creepypasta)
   • Margaret Woods
   • Timothy "Tim" Wright | Masky
   • Brian Thomas | Hoody
   • Smile Dog
   • Kagekao (Creepypasta)
   • Kate Milens | Kate the Chaser
   • Ben (BEN Drowned)
   • Dina Angela Clark | Judge Angels
   • Natalie Ouellette | Clockwork
   • Jonathan Blake | The Puppeteer
   • Candy Pop (Creepypasta)
   • Lazari Natalie Swann
   • Jason Meyer | Jason the Toymaker
   • Zalgo (Creepypasta)
   • Reader-Insert
   • Slow Romance
   • Confusion
   • Female Reader-Insert
   • Creepypasta
   • Five Stages of Grief
   • Developing Friendships
   • Loss of Parent(s)
   • It's Not Paranoia If They're Really out to Get You
   • The Author Regrets Nothing
   • How Do I Tag
   • Fluff until I burn it into angst
   • Inspired by a Cigarettes After Sex Song
   • I Wrote This While Listening To Lana Del Rey's Music
   • No beta reader we die like everyone's sanity in this story
   • Toxic Relationships
   • Coming of age is a mess
   • Teenage years are a mess
   • mental health

   Summary

   You woke up one day, and suddenly, all of your creepypasta searches disappeared, with Google saying no such things exists. You head to school confused and end up meeting new people, who reminded you an awful lot like the creepypastas backstorys...

   (I kinda wanna make this funny for you guys but like serious y'know? Thanks for reading!)

   *also on wattpad

   Language:

   English

   Words:

   33,202

   Chapters:

   16/?

   Comments:

   96

   Kudos:

   545

   Bookmarks:

   47

   Hits:

   11,118

   Bookmarked by Ariden

   25 Oct 2024