Work Text:
The Wheeler house had become Robin's second home.
Not because she spent a lot of time there, but because it actually felt like a home, Robin's home felt like a house.
“Hi, sweetheart,” Karen said, smiling at Nancy first, then Robin. “You made it.”
Robin ducked her head automatically, grinning. “Hi, Mrs. Wheeler. Hi. Hello. Hi. Sorry, um hi.”
Nancy squeezed her hand in warning amusement. “Robin.”
“I know, I know,” Robin said, lowering her voice by exactly half a notch. “Inside voice.”
Karen laughed, the sound light and genuine. “You don’t have to apologize for being yourself Robin.”
Karens kindness always did something strange to Robin’s chest.
At some point later on, Nancy glanced at the clock. “I’m gonna shower before we settle in. Robin, you wanna help my mom with the cookies?”
Robin froze mid-sentence.
“Oh. Uh. Yeah. Yeah, I can, I mean, if she wants help. I don’t wanna, like, get in the way or,”
“I want help,” Karen said immediately, already pulling a recipe card from the counter. “And you are wonderful company Robin.”
When Nancy disappeared up the stairs, the kitchen felt bigger somehow. Quieter, but not uncomfortable. Karen handed Robin an apron.
“Okay,” Karen said, tying her own apron strings.
“Chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, or oatmeal?”
Robin blinked. “You’re asking me?”
Karen raised an eyebrow. “Of course I am.”
Robin stared at the counter like it might give her answers. “Chocolate chip. Always chocolate chip.
Oatmeal is… I mean, oatmeal is fine, but chocolate chip feels like… home. If home were good. Which is, um wow. That sounded sadder than I meant it.”
Karen didn’t flinch. She just slid a bag of chocolate chips across the counter. “ Chocolate chip it is.”
They worked side by side, measuring flour, cracking eggs. Robin talked, she always talked, about school, about the weird dream she’d had the night before, and talked about the radio show.
Karen laughed in all the right places. Asked questions. Didn’t rush her, didn’t tell her to slow down.
And slowly, without meaning to, Robin started talking about other things.
“She thinks I do it on purpose,” Robin said suddenly, scraping batter from a spoon. “Like, the talking. Like I’m trying to be rude.”
Karen paused. “Your mother?”
Robin nodded, eyes fixed on the bowl. “She’s always telling me to slow down. Or that I interrupt. Or that I sound… aggressive.” She laughed weakly. “Which is funny, because I am terrified of confrontation.”
Karen leaned against the counter, listening.
“She says I talk too much, too fast, too loud. That people don’t take me seriously because I don’t know when to stop.” Robin swallowed. “And I try, I really do. But my brain just, it’s like I'm wired differently than everyone else.”
“Oh, honey,” Karen said softly.
Robin waved a hand, trying to brush it off. “I mean, she’s not mean. She just… looks at me like I’m exhausting. Like I’m a chore. And sometimes she says I embarrass her. And sometimes she says I’m too much and then immediately asks why I’m so quiet when I stop talking it kinda confuses me”
Her voice cracked on the last word. She pretended not to notice.
Karen, placed a gentle hand over Robin’s on the counter. “Robin, there is nothing wrong with you.”
Robin laughed, sharp and disbelieving. “You say that because you don’t live with me.”
“I say that because I see you,” Karen replied. “I don’t don’t need to live with you to see that you’re a wonderful woman Robin.”
Robin’s throat tightened. She focused very hard on breathing.
“You don’t need to be quieter,” Karen continued.
“You don’t need to be smaller. And you certainly don’t need to apologize for being yourself.”
Robin nodded quickly, eyes burning. “Yeah. Yeah, I know. It’s just—”
She didn’t finish the sentence.
Karen squeezed her hand once, reassuring, then went back to the cookies like nothing fragile had been placed between them. Like Robin hadn’t just cracked herself open a little.
When the cookies went into the oven, Karen set a timer and smiled at Robin. “Why don’t you go upstairs and relax? I’ll call you when they’re done.”
Robin hesitated. “Are you sure? I can stay. I don’t mind.”
“I know you don’t,” Karen said warmly. “But you’re a guest. And Nancy’s probably finished her shower.”
Robin nodded, tugging off the apron. “Okay. Yeah. Okay.”
She climbed the stairs slowly, Nancy’s door was open, steam still drifting from the bathroom down the hall. Robin stepped inside the bedroom and sat on the edge of the bed.
And then it hit her.
All of it.
The kindness. The way Karen had listened. The way she hadn’t once told Robin to slow down or quiet down or tone it down. The way she’d said I see you.
Robin folded in on herself, hands gripping the hem of her shirt, and started to cry.
Not quiet tears.
She sobbed like something had finally broken loose.
Nancy walked in moments later, hair damp, wearing matching pajama pants and a top. She froze when she saw Robin curled on the bed.
“Robin? What's the matter?” she said softly.
Robin looked up, eyes red, face blotchy, breath hitching. “Your mom is so nice,” she choked out. “She’s so nice and sweet and I don’t deserve it and I don’t deserve you and I don’t—”
Nancy crossed the room, and pulled Robin into her arms.
“Oh, Robin,” Nancy murmured, holding her tightly as Robin cried into her shoulder. “Hey. Hey. It’s okay. You’re okay.”
Robin clutched at her like she was afraid she might disappear. “She was just, she was so kind. And she listened. And I’m not used to that. And I know that sounds stupid-”
“It doesn’t,” Nancy said firmly. “It really doesn’t.”
Robin shook, tears soaking into Nancy’s shirt. “I’m always the strong one. I’m always the funny one. I don’t, I don’t cry like this.”
“I know,” Nancy whispered, rubbing soothing circles into her back. “I’ve got you.”
They stayed like that for a long time. Until Robin’s sobs softened into shaky breaths. Until her grip loosened just a little.
“You deserve kindness,” Nancy said quietly, pressing a kiss into Robin’s hair. “From my mom. From me. From everyone.”
Robin nodded against her, exhausted but held.
Downstairs, the timer rang. Cookies cooled on the counter.
Nancy didn’t let go when Robin’s breathing finally evened out.
She stayed exactly where she was, one arm wrapped firmly around Robin’s shoulders, the other hand rubbing circles on her back. Robin’s face was buried against her collarbone, damp curls sticking to her cheeks. She felt wrung out, emptied, like she’d finally set something heavy down and didn’t yet know how to stand without it.
“I’m sorry,” Robin whispered hoarsely.
Nancy pulled back just enough to look at her. Her eyes were soft, but serious. “Don’t.”
Robin swallowed hard. “It’s embarrassing.”
Nancy shook her head. “It’s human.”
That almost set her off again.
“I’m usually the one holding you,” Robin said after a moment, voice small. “You cry. I make jokes. I distract you. I keep it together.”
Nancy smiled sadly. “You don’t have to keep it together all the time, you’re human.”
“I don’t know how not to,” Robin admitted. “If I fall apart, who’s left?”
Nancy cupped her face carefully, making Robin look at her. “Me. You always have me.”
Robin’s lips trembled.
There was a knock at the door a few minutes later. Soft. Careful.
“Nancy? Robin?” Karen’s voice floated in. “Cookies are cooling.”
Nancy glanced at Robin, silently asking. Robin hesitated, then nodded.
“Come in,” Nancy said.
Karen opened the door slowly and stopped short when she saw Robin’s red eyes, her tear-streaked face. Her expression didn’t change to shock or discomfort, just understanding.
“Oh sweetheart are you alright?” she said quietly as she set the cookies down.
Robin nodded and wiped her eyes.
Karen reached out, hesitating only briefly before resting a hand over Robin’s knee. “Do you want a hug?”
Robin blinked, then nodded.
Karen pulled her in slowly, carefully, like she was handling something precious. Robin stiffened for half a second, instinct, and then melted, arms wrapping around Karen’s waist as another quiet sob slipped out.
Karen held her like she’d done it a hundred times before.
“You are always welcome here,” Karen murmured into her hair. “Always.”
Robin cried again, silently this time.
Nancy watched them with a tight throat, something warm and aching in her chest. This was what she’d always wished Robin could have a mother figure who would care for Robin like she deserves.
Karen pulled back eventually, smoothing Robin’s hair. “Why don’t you girls enjoy cookies and milk tonight?” she suggested. “A proper sleepover deserves proper snacks.”
Robin nodded mutely.
Karen smiled. “I’ll bring the milk.”
When she left, Robin exhaled shakily. “Your mom is going to ruin me for life.”
They lay there, tangled together, Robin’s head tucked under Nancy’s chin, fingers absently playing with the hem of Nancy’s pajama shirt.
“I think,” Robin said quietly, “that I’ve spent my whole life trying to be… accepted.”
Nancy stiffened slightly. “What do you mean?”
“Like,” Robin continued, staring at the ceiling “if I talk less, or slower, or only when asked then maybe I’ll be easier to love.”
Nancy’s heart clenched. “You never have to earn love from me.”
Robin turned her head, meeting Nancy’s eyes. “You don’t get tired of me?”
Nancy didn’t even hesitate. “Never.”
Robin let out a shaky laugh. “God, I love you.”
“I know,” Nancy said softly. “I love you too.”
Karen returned with a tray a few minutes later and set it on the desk, pretending not to notice when Robin wiped at her eyes again. She stayed for a little while, telling a light story about the time Nancy put bows in 2 year old Mike’s hair.
When she finally left, turning out the hall light behind her, the house settled into a gentle quiet.
Robin changed into pajamas, soft pj pants and a tanktop. She usually falls asleep with a hoodie on but not since the heShe curled up under the covers, exhaustion pulling at her limbs.
Nancy clicked off the lamp and climbed in beside her.
For a long moment, neither of them spoke.
Then Robin whispered, “Thank you for just letting me be me.”
Nancy kissed her temple. “Of course.”
Robin’s fingers laced with hers. “I don’t cry like that. Ever.”
Robin smiled faintly in the dark. “Next time you cry I'll hold you.”
Nancy smiled back. “Deal.”
Robin drifted off like that, being held by her girlfriend, and it was perfect and she felt loved.