Archive of Our Own

The door gives a well-known squeak as you enter the old building and head for the stairs leading to the practice room. A room you have been sharing with several musicians over the past two years, a room where you´ve been lately hanging out with Josh and Ty after accidentally intruding on one of their sessions.

It has become sort of a habit. You, coming in early when they are in the middle of their practice, listening to whatever they created or even jamming with them from time to time. Other times when the ideas just aren't coming, you end up just hanging out, talking about life or eating some cheap take-out. Sometimes you even give up your own practice time so that all of you can hang out together a little bit longer.

...

"Hey guys," you said as you stepped through the door, throwing your bag next to it and waving hello.

"Hiya," Josh replied and you only got a silent nod from Tyler.

Today, Tyler asked you to come in earlier because he had a new song idea to show you and wanted your opinion. You were expecting the two of them to perform together, introducing an up-beat song with Josh's witty drumming and Tyler´s deep lyrics and catchy sounds. What you didn't expect was Josh being as much in the dark as you were, not knowing what Tyler had prepared, but by the way Ty kept fidgeting it seemed he was nervous about it. Which meant it was probably deep and personal.

So you found yourself sitting beside Joshua on the old couch in the corner that has definitely seen some better times, both of you equally excited about what Tyler is about to show you, sharing a look of complete cluelessness.

"Alright," was the only thing Tyler said before he hit the first key on the piano, no time to waste.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

The thing about Tylers ideas was just how much from the heart they all were. It should be illegal for them to also sound so good and be catchy at the same time. Not to mention that if somehow, the music itself didn't mesmerize you all on its own, then Tyler and his infinite beauty definitely would.

It didn't really take you long to develop a crush on the singer after you started hanging out with the guys. You were smitten as soon as you heard him sing, listening to lyrics that were deep, meaningful and beyond anything you´ve ever heard and watching his fingers effortlessly dance along the piano keys. It didn't really help your case that he had this kind of intimidating aura that just made you melt into the floor every time he looked you in the eyes. Fortunately for you though, that happened very rarely, because he was always so absorbed in the music or in his own thoughts.

So that's how you kept coming to their sessions, huddled on the creepy couch by yourself, eating some candy or chewing on a gum and sometimes writing down your own ideas after being inspired by them. Most of the time though, the pencil was unconsciously stuck between your lips as you kept openly watching Tyler bring to life whatever he was working on and appreciating that both boys had their attention on their instruments, so nobody noticed you staring. Sometimes you offered your feedback when they asked for it, sometimes you even fell asleep to Tylers soothing voice and sometimes you were buzzing with energy, which usually ended up with you pacing the place and annoying Josh behind the drums.

Your favorite moments though were those when you just got to hang out with them and talk about life. You felt so content in their presence, you felt so understood and appreciated that it didn't cross your mind once to actually act on your feelings and make any sort of move on Tyler, because you wouldn't want to lose his and Josh's friendship for a silly reason like having a stupid crush.

You often thought about how well the two of them worked together despite there being a lot of differences between them. Josh was like a human puppy, he was usually cheerful, all smiles and he never failed when you needed to boost your mood. You loved his energy so much that sometimes it brought up a strong urge to just hug him until both of you couldn't breathe. But for the same reason as not making a move on Tyler, you kept those urges to yourself, afraid that he might be weirded out by you. It was enough that you made a habit of bugging him and annoying him when you were feeling cheeky. But he always just giggled or softly pushed you away when it was becoming too much. You just couldn't help it though, his laugh was so contagious.

Tyler on the other hand could be a little unpredictable, you never knew what mood he was in and you felt like sometimes you had to tiptoe around him just in case he was irritated. Mostly he was just a chill guy though, he could talk about whatever for hours and his opinions never lacked depth or well thought arguments. You admired how his mind works and you loved listening to him just talk or even just watching his lips move. Whenever he was talking directly to you though, all his attention was fully on you and sometimes it was so intense that you found yourself speechless. He somehow owned the room just by being in it. And this kind of intensity and authority he had around him was probably what made you crush on him so hard. You realized you just wanted to soak up in it, fall to your knees and worship the king.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Right now though, as Tyler was playing an unfamiliar melody and singing unfamiliar words, you couldn't seem to catch your breath while you watched him. It was magic happening right in front of your eyes. Enchantment flowing through your ears and stimulating something in your brain that just made it impossible to look away.

Suddenly you felt overwhelmed by the music, by the raw emotions from Tyler, by his effortless playing and the pure intensity of the song. The way he swayed on the stool, the way his fingers moved along the keys and how his eyes kept closing to feel out the intimate parts of the song, it was all too much not to leave you amazed.

You were so gone that you forgot Josh's presence next to you, as well as you didn´t notice how he caught the hitch in your breath or the way you bit your lower lip everytime Tyler played with his eyes closed. You didn´t see how he watched you with a slightly questioning look in his expression the whole time, up to the point when Tyler rose from the piano and walked towards both of you, asking for opinion.

...

"............her completely speechless, man," you caught the ending of the phrase when you realized that both of them were now staring at you with an amused expression, which finally snapped you from your coma. You felt warmth flow into your cheeks under their gaze, feeling flustered and embarrassed.

"That good, huh?" Tyler asked, smirking and probably feeling proud of himself.

You wanted to form some sort of an answer, but still found yourself short of words. Luckily, Josh beat you to it.

"Yeah, man, I mean... Perhaps you finally wrote a song that will make my sister shut up for a while," he joked.

"Yeah, I wouldn't be that optimistic, bro...," Tyler continued the conversation, which you were ultimately glad for, since it took the attention from you and your perplexed expression, giving you some time to compose yourself.

"No but really," Tyler said after a while, averting his gaze back to you, "what did you think of it?"

No words could ever express whatever effect the song had on you, which is exactly what you told Tyler. And that seemed to be enough for him for now.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

After their time in the practice room ran up, the two guys said their goodbyes and left, heading to the parking lot outside the building. Tyler was talking about being hungry and going for a bite to Taco Bell, but Josh only half-listened because he was deep in thoughts after today's session.

"Hey, you okay..?" Tyler asked when he noticed that Josh was kind of spaced out. He slowed down and brushed his hand against his, but Josh only stopped for a moment, looking up towards the window of the practice room, silently thinking before he furrowed his brows and continued to walk towards the car.

"Josh, what´s up?" Tyler asked again as he caught up to him, both of them opening the door.

...

"I think she's got a thing for you, Ty," Josh finally spoke as they stepped into the car, turning to face the singer.

"What do you mean?" Tyler looked up from the steering wheel, focusing on Josh's face.

He knew what Josh meant, he was not oblivious. He was probably the most observant person in the room and even though he gave off the impression of being too focused on his work, he knew very well what was going on. He didn't mind it, he was flattered if anything. And he didn't plan to do anything about it either, except maybe wait for Josh to notice, which brings them back to the current situation.

Josh leaned closer over the console and looked into Tyler's eyes. "I mean, I know how it feels to be enthralled by Tyler Joseph and I am telling you she´s got it bad for you," he let his gaze fall to Tyler's lips and lingered there while licking his own unconsciously.

Tyler's eyes copied Josh's movement before he leaned back an inch, studying his face for any sign of annoyance or jealousy, surprised when he found none.

"Oh," he said simply before leaning back even more, trying to read Josh's body language.

"I suppose you might be right.. Does that... does that bother you?" Tyler narrowed his eyes as he looked at Josh.

Josh held his gaze for a moment before he averted his eyes down in his lap and bit on his bottom lip, shrugging.

Now that got Tylers attention. You see, it wasn´t such a long time ago when Josh openly threatened a certain crew member of a certain venue that tried to flirt with Tyler backstage after their show. He was almost fuming back then, his whole presence radiating with jealousy and once the person almost ran away, he made sure that Tyler got the message that he belonged to him. It was one of the few times when Tyler let Josh be in charge and he let him mark him up against the green room door that night.

So imagine Tylers surprise when Josh let out a silent "I dunno, it doesn't... it doesn't really bother me, Ty."

"Wha.. how-uh.. Josh," he was speechless for a moment.

"How does that not bother you, you were ready to rip the throat of that guy who flirted with me last month. And he wasn't even flirting that hard. How does this not both...," his voice faded out when he saw a smidge of blush on Josh's cheeks. He silently gasped with a quick realization.

"Oh my god... God, Josh... you like her, don´t you? You´re attracted to her?," he asked.

Josh said nothing, keeping his gaze down on his fingers that were currently nervously picking at his calluses. He felt ashamed and scared. This is not a known territory for him and he felt like a hypocrite. He was a jealous asshole just a few weeks ago when that dude was sweet talking Tyler backstage and now he felt very torn from the inside. He did like her. How could he not. He liked her personality and the way she smiled and laughed at his jokes. He even liked when she tried to annoy him, only for them both to end up giggling about it. He also liked the way she appreciated Tyler, just the same way that he did. He knew where she was coming from and he couldn't help but adore her.

Tyler sensed his uneasiness and decided to treat the matter a little more delicately than he normally would. Giving Josh his space to sort out his thoughts before touching his chin softly, making him look up into his eyes. He held his gaze with a soft but curious expression.

"Josh," he whispered, "you can be honest with me, you know how I feel about this sort of stuff," he continued, sliding his thumb along Josh's jaw absentmindedly. "Do you like her?"

Josh leaned into his touch and sighed deeply. "I don't know Ty. I think.. I might?" He looked genuinely torn while saying that and it made Tyler want to hug him tightly. Instead he slid his hand across his cheek, giving him an assuring look.

"Hey," he said soothingly. "It's okay. You don't have to figure it out now, just ... you know if that's something you want to explore, you know it can happen."

Josh scoffed, the whole situation suddenly frustrating him more and more.

"Even if I wanted to.... explore this more, or whatever, last time I checked she had a crush on you, not me, dude. Not to mention she probably doesn't even know that we are together, Tyler. What is there for me to figure out, really..," he raised his voice in frustration.

Tyler straightened in his seat, his hand leaving Josh's jaw just for his fingers to lock inside his red curls. Josh's breath hitched when those fingers tightened slightly. "Now now Joshua, watch your tone," he said while he made the drummer look into his eyes again.

"You should know by now how this works. She wants me? Good. Okay. But she doesn't get me without getting you as well. And how much of you or me it is, that is for me to decide. You understand that, right?" He challenged with a raised eyebrow, tugging on the locks more firmly and leaning even closer to Josh, who whined softly and nodded his head.

"Good, then you also understand that I need to know if it's something you wanna pursue, because if it's not, then she gets nothing," he said, his eyes never breaking eye contact. "But if it is.. we invite her into this and she can either take it or leave it."

Tyler let the silence overtake the situation for a little while, his hand still in Josh's hair and he pressed their foreheads together, letting their breaths mix in silent anticipation. Selfishly, he kind of wished Josh would surrender, feeling excited by the idea of the three of them together.

"You say the word, Joshua," his lips ghosted the others as he spoke and Josh finally gave in.

"Yes. Yes I want it. I want her."

Tyler inhaled at Josh's confession, letting out a breathy "Okay.."

"Okay," he repeated and pulled on Joshed locks, closing the distance between them and bringing their lips together in a surprisingly heated kiss. He felt Josh finally relax under his hands as he kissed him back.

"How do we..," Josh started and was silenced by Tylers lips once again.

"You leave that up to me, baby."

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Tyler and Josh were locked inside the practice room today, which.. okay.. unusual? but you still raised your hand to knock and loudly announced yourself behind the door.

You were met with a very intense look from Tyler when he the door opened. He gave you a silent once over before steadying his gaze on your face. It almost seemed like he was waiting for you to say some secret password or something as he steadily held your eye contact. You felt your face flush, whether it was because of Tylers attention or the unusual silent confrontation between the door, you don´t know, but it was enough for him to finally step aside and let you in, only giving you a simple "Hmm.."  while narrowing his eyes. What was up with him today?

You waved hello to Josh and took your usual spot on the couch, putting your hair in a ponytail, because it was way too warm both outside and in the room as well. You only stopped your movements when you realized that both boys were watching you instead of fumbling with their instruments like they usually would.

"Um... what- is going on?" you asked, eying them both suspiciously.

Both boys seemed to be buzzing with a different kind of energy today. One that you just didn't seem to be able to decode. Josh was behind his drums, but instead of doing his usual maintenance, he just sat on the stool with hands in his lap, switching his gaze between you, Tyler and his lap, and looking a little nervous or maybe even sheepish. Tyler on the other hand took a pose next to his piano, leaning his hip against it and folding his arms over his chest, while he kept his gaze on you and there seemed to be an internal battle going on behind his eyes, while the room was still completely silent.

He pursed his lips and stepped aside from the piano, making his way towards Josh until he was standing right behind him. He put his hands on his shoulders and kneaded his fingers in, which seemed to have an immediate effect on Josh, as he closed his eyes and let out a long sigh. It was almost as if Tyler felt his nervous energy and helped him let it out. The whole scene seemed almost.. domestic. You watched Josh's expression change, his shoulder relaxed under Tylers touch and his head fell back a little, making contact with the taller boy's tummy.

It probably wouldn't feel as weird as it did, if Tyler's eyes weren't focused on you the whole time.

Not to mention your earlier question was completely ignored.

"Okay, how about this," Tyler began talking after a while, letting go of Josh's shoulder, just to give him a few light slaps across one cheek. The sound was unproportionally loud in the silent room, but it did make Josh sort of wake up from his haze and focus on what Tyler was saying.

"I say we pack up our stuff, get out of here and go to my place. We order pizza, play some sick records and hang out by the pool. God knows it's way too hot to be rehearsing today anyway." He looked down at Josh nodding his approval, his hands now hanging loosely around his neck.
You felt so confused right now, nothing made sense today.

"Um," you began uncertainly "are you guys giving up your time in the room to me then, or..." but you didn't even get to finish your sentence before Tyler interrupted you.

"Oh nonononononono, you´re coming with us, sweetie."

"If you want," Josh added and Tyler gave him a single tap on the chest, before looking back at you.

"I-," you paused, looking at Tyler who had an unreadable expression on his face. "Did you say pool?"

"Oh yeah, all fifty hundred square feet of it," he finally gave out a cheeky grin.

Okay, how can one say no to an offer like that? Especially when both boys were looking excited by the idea and were waiting patiently for you to say yes. Who are you to decline?

"Oh, but... I don't have anything to wear, I don´t exactly bring my bikini to rehearsals" you realized after entertaining the thought for a bit longer, your smile fading a little bit.

Josh's smile faded as well and he looked up at Tyler, looking at him like he was supposed to bring a solution to this unfortunate situation.

Tyler gave a thoughtful expression, before he locked yes with you, something else playing behind his eyes. His gaze slid down your form, looking at the flowery dress you were wearing and then back up.

"Well..," he paused to lick his lower lip, "are you wearing any underwear under that dress?" He leaned in over Josh, with his hands back on his shoulders and his mouth was left slightly opened as he waited for your reaction.

You felt your eyebrows fly high on your forehead as your eyes widened. Your breath hitched and you suddenly felt so tiny under Tylers gaze, thinking your heartbeat must be loud enough for both of them to hear. If you weren't sweating before, now you definitely were and it was not from the heat. What the hell was happening today?!

"I- of course I am," you finally choked out.

Tyler gave you one last tiny smile before he tapped Josh's shoulders and went to grab his belongings, "Well then it´s settled. Let's go!"

You were expecting at least an apologetic look from Josh, but when you looked over at him, you were met with something completely different. There was heat behind his gaze that you´ve never seen before. One that could only be translated as want. But that didn't make any sense. Or did it?

No, nothing made sense today.
__________________________________

You excused yourself to the bathroom as soon as you arrived at Tyler's place. He gave you instructions to go upstairs and left with Josh to the kitchen. You managed to calm yourself down a little bit during the ride here, but still wanted to freshen up and maybe make sure that you weren't dreaming.

This was your crush inviting you to his home after all.

You remembered his earlier comment about your underwear and saw your cheeks heat up again as you looked at yourself in the mirror. Christ, were you actually going to take off your clothes in front of him? At least Josh was there too. Somehow he seemed like your anchor not to go completely insane in this situation. This was just a friendly hang out, you reminded yourself and tried not to get any other ideas as you opened the door to exit the bathroom.

As you walked towards the staircase leading back to the hall, you could hear two muffled voices from the kitchen downstairs, having a quiet conversation.

"...but Ty, I thought we agreed to let her know before we made any kind of move though," Josh said softly.

"Hey, no move has been made yet. Besides, I'm quite certain about this. Just go with the plan... Trust me, Jish," Tyler replied.

Jish and Ty, what a cute nickname they had for each other, you thought as you descended down the stairs, completely ignoring the topic of their conversation.

"But what if..," Josh's voice reached your ears again, only to be interrupted by Tylers strict tone.

"Joshua." "I thought I told you to leave this up to me, didn't I?"

Silence...

"Look at me," he said again and your knees almost gave out under you as you took the last step. The authority was oozing from his voice. You had no idea why he talked to Josh like that or even what the conversation was about, but the effect seemed to reach you just as much.

"Do you trust me?" Tyler asked again and there was a silent "yes," from Josh.

The last thing you heard Tyler say was a soft "good boy," before you made an appearance in front of them, taking in the scene in front of you.

Tyler had Josh cornered against the kitchen counter, his hand on Josh's face, holding his jaw firmly and squeezing his cheeks with his fingers, their eyes locked on each other. When Tyler noticed you, he simply released Josh from his hold and patted his hand on his cheek again like he did earlier in the practice room today.

"Let´s go for that swim, shall we?" he asked like nothing happened, before walking away and leaving you confused and a flustered Josh behind.

You looked at Josh questioningly, but he just shrugged at you and followed Tyler out to the pool.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

The time in the pool was surprisingly nice. Tyler decided to mix up a few drinks before you all jumped in, then both guys decided to go in their underwear too, so that you didn't feel discriminated. When you were pulling off your dress and getting in the water, they turned around to give you some privacy, which was also a nice gesture, but the water was still translucent, so you knew they were gonna get a glimpse of the goods sooner or later.

But boy, did the same thing apply to them. This was the first time you saw them with their clothes off, Tyler´s tattoos immediately catching your attention and Josh´s abs were also not the worst sight in the world. They didn't leave you enough time to stare though, because soon they were either swimming, kicking water, playing with a floating unicorn, diving each other's head underwater or actually doing synchronized jumps, which lef you giggling when they failed or landed in a funny way.

They just resurfaced from another jump, when Tyler´s phone began ringing. He swam across to the edge of the pool, where he earlier threw his clothes along with the device and answered it. Leaving you and Josh to entertain each other for a while.

Josh dipped under water and then his head appeared right in front of you as he shaked it to get water from his hair and ears, grinning widely.

The time seemed to have slowed down as you watched the movement. This was probably the closest proximity you two have been next to each other and maybe it was the heat or the bit of alcohol you had running in your system, but you suddenly realized that he is quite beautiful. His kind smile that always reached his eyes, the droplets of water slowly falling down his face, or the way he just held your eye contact while the sun was dazzling his features.

You kept looking at each other for what seemed like a lifetime, just smiling and swaying in the water together. Josh absentmindedly licked his lips as his gaze suddenly fell down to yours, making you involuntarily do the same, as if you were under some kind of spell. When did Josh get so beautiful? How did you not notice it before?

You were interrupted from your thoughts when you heard a loud splash of water. Tyler was getting out of the pool, still with the phone on his ear as he headed inside the house mumbling a quiet "Hold on, let me check." Your gaze followed his tanned body, legs moving, wet feet squelching on the warm tiles by the pool and you watched as he bent down to pick up his towel, trying to dry himself quickly before he disappeared inside his home.

When you turned back to Josh, you found him still looking at you, as if he was watching you watch Tyler. His expression changed though and it was no longer grinning and playful, it was more serious, thoughtful and maybe even nervous. He looked like he wanted to say something.

Before you had the chance to ask, he beat you to it.

"I know you like him," he said simply.

You froze in the water before your body betrayed you and you felt a blush rise to your cheeks. That was not something you expected him to say at all. You dipped half your face under the water, trying to cool it down, or maybe wishing it would hide your embarrassed reaction. Sensing it wouldn´t help you in any case, you resurfaced again.

"Josh..," you began talking, but were interrupted once again.

"Tyler knows too."

If you felt embarrassed before, it was nothing compared to now. You looked away in the direction where Tyler disappeared a few moments before, thankfully the space was still empty. You raised both your hands to palm your face, hiding in them for a little moment, thinking maybe it would make you disappear. You had no idea why Josh was telling you this, but as you pulled your hands away to look at him again, it seemed that he wasn't done talking.

He took a tiny step closer, his face showing empathy and understanding. "It's..., it's fine.. he's okay with it. We´re okay with it."

" We´re..."

You frowned and tried to replay the sentence in your head again.

"We´re... what... what do you mean, we´re... okay with it," you asked, confusion showing on your face apparently, because Josh looked down, suddenly nervous. He bit his lip before looking at you again, taking a deep breath.

"We..I.. there´s something we wanted to tell you for a while," he paused, looking away before he continued, "but.. there was never really a good time and now it´s..."

He looked like he had difficulty finding the right words, his mouth opening and closing once or twice before he scrunched his face.

"Tyler and I are dating," he finally said. "We've been together for almost four years now."

You felt a thrill run through your whole body and not in a good way.

It felt like a slap in the face. It felt like your lungs were suddenly suffocated and you couldn't get a breath in or out. The reality of the situation suddenly hit you like a rock and you felt yourself getting dizzy. What the hell. How could you read this whole thing so wrong?

Josh once again tried to help by saying "Hey, it's okay," but he didn't get to finish his sentence as you whined an "Oh my god," leaning your head back harsly to avoid his gaze and possibly this whole situation.

"Jesus Josh, Oh my god... this is so embarrassing, I don´t know how I didn´t see the signs. Fuck," you palmed your face again. "And here I was actually thinking he might like me back," you said with a desperation in your voice, feeling absolutely pathetic.

"He does. We both do," Josh tried to reach out for your hand, but your reaction was faster and you dodged his move, taking a step away.

That didn't make any sense. You felt the humiliation run through your body, shaking with nerves. You took another step away from Josh, feeling that there was no choosing between fight or flight, there was definitely only one option and that was FLIGHT. Immediately.

So you did. Stuttering a simple "I - I have to go," leaving a broken hearted Josh behind.

You quickly swam to the stairs, getting out as fast as you could, picking up your towel and your dress from the floor in the process and bolting to the only room in the house that you were familiar with, the bathroom. You closed the door behind you before finally losing all composure and sliding down against it and breathing heavily.

What the hell just happened? How did you not see it sooner? Jesus, it was there all along. Their subtle touches, them being so close to each other all the time, even the situation from earlier today, when Tyler spoke to Josh in the kitchen, being only a few inches away from kissing him.

Tears began to gather around your eyelashes threatening to fall down your cheeks.

Did your crush on Tyler blind you so much that you did not realize two of your good friends were actually in a relationship?

And that wasn´t even the worst of it. The worst part was that they both knew about your crush. Pathetic.

The tears finally spilled.

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________-

Meanwhile, Tyler was already off the phone and was changing from his swim trunks into dry shorts when Josh burst into their bedroom, breathing heavily with tears in his eyes.

"Ty.. I think I fucked up. I fucked it up," he said as he began pacing the room and pulled on his hair with one hand.

Tyler immediately went after him, stopping him with both hands on his arms, making Josh look him in the eye.

"Hey, hey...it's okay, breathe with me," he instructed and took a deep breath, waiting for Josh to join him. "It´s okay, I´m here. In and out...," he said softly.

Eventually Josh managed to calm down a little bit, grounded by Tyler´s hands, who still had a strong grip on him.

"Tell me what happened," Tyler asked.

A hurtful expression crossed Josh's face before he talked. "I told her... like we... like we said I would. And she - she ran away, I think she left, Ty.. I made her leave," his breath was picking up again.

"Hey, Joshie. It's alright, we talked about this," he took a cautious look at Josh, before making three steps to the bedroom door, looking out towards the kitchen and then getting back in front of Josh.

"She didn't leave, her bag is still on the kitchen table," he said softly and saw Josh relax a little. "And it´s okay. We knew there was a possibility of this happening," Tyler held Josh's gaze, trying to get him from his emotional state into a rational mind.

"Like we said, we tell her, we  might make a move and she can either take it or leave it. We said that, didn't we Josh?," he asked to make Josh communicate with him.

"Yes," he said softly. "We did, Ty, but I feel like I made the wrong move," he said, his face full of regret.

"No Josh, you did exactly what we said we´re gonna do. You didn´t make any move at all, you simply told her and this is how she took it. Her reaction was always out of your hands. You did good, Josh," Tyler leaned against his forehead and let his hand wander through Josh's wet hair softly. "You did nothing wrong."

Josh finally calmed down completely, so grounded by Tylers words, whispering a soft "Okay."

Tyler couldn't help but try to lighten up the situation. "Besides, what do you know, nothing is lost quite yet, Joshie," giving him a small smirk. Josh opened his mouth to oppose, but Ty stopped him.

"Like I said earlier, no move was made yet. And I told you to leave that up to me, didn´t I?"

Josh simply nodded, trying to find hope with Tylers words.

"Good, so you do just that. Now go get changed out of these wet trunks and meet me in the kitchen, I´m going to order the pizza," he reached down to squeeze Josh's butt, making him giggle. And that was the end of the conversation.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

You finally managed to rise from the floor, bending under the sink, splashing water over your face and lifting your head to stare at your reflection. You realized you are still in your wet underwear, so you made a quick move taking it off and slipping on your dress. Seems like there's no other option but going commando. Well, it will have to do. The only thing you wanted to do anyway, was to pack up your stuff, leave this house as quick as you can and go home to die of embarrassment.

That plan backfired when you were met with Tyler in the kitchen, who gave you a quick look over his shoulder and then turned back to continue typing something in his phone.

You didn't realize you were holding your breath until it automatically left your lungs in a long shuddering sigh. You were hoping that nobody would be here and definitely weren't going to make any conversation, so you only made a few long steps towards the kitchen table, intending to reach for your bag and leave without saying goodbye.

But of course the universe did not work in your favor today.

Tyler noticed your rush and stepped right behind you as you were reaching for your bag, successfully cutting off the only escape route from there. With just this simple movement he was cornering you against the table just like he cornered Josh just a few hours ago.

"Hey, what´s wrong?," he asked softly.

You averted your gaze to the floor and swallowed, trying to not make the situation worse than it already was. You genuinely didn´t know what to say, so you stayed silent, trying to will the universe to make you disappear into a black hole or teleport yourself just anywhere else.

A few more seconds of silence went by, before Ty spoke again.

"Oh..," he said with quiet understanding.

"Josh told you."

Thankfully you were out of tears for today, so you chanced a look at Tyler, his expression still soft, so you just shrugged and your head gave a subtle nod.

"Okay," he said calmly... "And... how do you feel about it?"

Your first thought was that they were just both trying to embarrass you as much as possible, making you pay for being stupid and oblivious and just punishing you on and on until your heart finally gave out and you died. But when you looked up and saw the uncertain look on Tyler´s face, it dawned on you, that maybe he might be anxious for a whole different reason.

They did just come out to you, after all. And that wasn't an easy thing to do.

And yet here you were, making the whole thing about yourself.

"I-," your voice gave out, so you tried again, "I- well, obviously I am happy for you guys," you said softly, your empathetic side rising for the occasion as you found it in yourself to take Tyler's hand and squeeze it lightly.

He looked surprised for a moment, his eyes following your joined hands, before he smiled and bowed his head down a little.

"That's good. I'm glad to hear that. Thank you," he continued "but I mean, how do youfeel about it?"

Oh my god, so he was asking you for that after all. You tried to pull your hand away, but he didn't let you, doing the same gesture as you did and giving you a light squeeze, as if telling you it's okay.

"Jesus Tyler," you gave in after a few seconds of silence, "I feel humiliated, okay? I mean.. I guess I was so deeply infatuated with you that I didn't notice what was really going on. And god, I was also so obvious about it that you both noticed. How pathetic is that? How can I feel any other way than utterly embarrassed Tyler."

The words began falling out of you and Tyler patiently waited to hear you out. "I can´t believe I actually thought that you might have invited me here because you liked me back and that you were maybe going to do something about it today. Oh my god."

As you finished your sentence, you wished Tyler wouldn't be standing so close to you, so that you could slip from under him and just finally run away.

But then he disarmed you with a simple. "Well, you never know," holding your gaze with an unreadable expression "I just might."

Your mouth opened and then closed again, unable to find a response to that.

So you only scoffed.

"Please don't - please don't joke about this," you said, your face twisting with hurt, you finally managed to get your hand out of his grasp and added "I think I´ll be leaving."

"Hold on," Tyler stopped you once again. His voice changed, sounding almost pleading and his expression matched the emotion.

"Please at least stay for dinner? I already ordered," he asked, "We´ll watch a movie or two and if you still wanna leave after that, I´ll drive you home."

You sighed deeply. It was painfully true that you had no plan on how to get home from here, considering you had no idea where you actually were. And even after everything that happened today, you still couldn't seem to be able to say no to him.

"Fine," you gave up. "But If I am staying, I want another drink."

"Now that can be arranged, princess," Tyler said in a singing voice and finally stepped aside, so you could move.

"Good, make it stronger," you said as you walked away towards the living room. "And larger."

Tyler was already on the move to the fridge to get out what he needed when he replied, "As you wish," with a prolonged shhhhhh pressed from between his teeth.

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

The pizza turned out to be a nice distraction, even after the emotional whirlwind that you just went though, you were parched and starving and having your mouth full of tasty food was the best way to deal with anything anyway.

You all ended up on the couch together, Tyler sitting to your left, between you and Josh. It wasn't exactly a large seating, so while there might have been no direct contact, you were sitting pretty close to each other. That's why, when they put on some unknown movie, you were barely able to keep up with it for the whole first half of it. But after a while you finally relaxed and managed to laugh along with them to some of the stupid jokes.

The thing is nobody was making a big deal out of it. The guys didn't change the way they were acting towards you, the energy in the room came back to their usual banter and when the first movie ended, you felt as if nothing had happened. It almost felt normal again.

You were hit with a realization, that it doesn't really have to be a big deal on your side either, thinking back to the time where you swore you´re never going to do anything about your crush just because you didn't want to lose them as friends. Well, and that still applied.

Except something has shifted when the second movie started.

Tyler got up to get the three of you another drink and when he came back with it, he sat much more closer to you on the couch, making full contact with the lower half of your body. It might have been the alcohol, it might have been the fact that even though you felt strong appreciation for your friendship, the crush didn't just disappear on the hour, but you felt an involuntary shudder run through your body.

And from there it only continued to get worse. Or better.

Ten minutes into the movie, you felt a slide of fabric against your leg and when you looked down, you saw Tyler´s fingers playing with the hem of your dress. Shocked, you looked up to his face, only to find him completely enthralled with the movie, his eyes firmly on the screen.

You decided not to say anything and try not to pay too much attention to it, but when his hand stopped playing with the fabric and began tracing little patterns along the skin of your thigh, your breath actually hitched. You looked up once again, to see if Tyler noticed, but you found the same expression as before.

You tried to tell yourself that he was probably not aware of his actions, but there was a thought back in your mind that told you it might not be entirely true.

"Well, you never know, I just might," his earlier words flashed through your memory and you looked up at him again, thinking you saw a small flash of smirk on his face.

Heat immediately pooled between your legs and your heart began to beat faster when you also remembered that you were wearing no underwear. What a convenience.

Jesus.

While you were silently panicking in your thoughts, Tyler´s hand moved a tiny bit higher, rumpling the fabric of your dress along the way and making goosebumps rise all over you.

You tried to compose your breath, not wanting to make it obvious how much a simple touch like that affected you, but then it flashed in your mind that it might be a lost battle already when Tyler innocently sighed next to you and slid his fingers to your inner thigh.

Well, after everything that has happened today, you really had nothing to lose, so you decided to be bold for a moment and shifted on the couch slightly, so that your legs spreaded and if what you thought was happening was really happening, Tyler had now a very easy access to continue where you wanted him the most.

You saw him take a deep breath and bite his lip in your peripheral vision.

So it worked. So it is happening. While Josh is in the room, unaware of anything. WHILE JOSH IS SITTING NEXT TO HIM.

Christ. Guilt tried to find its way into your head, but it was quickly forgotten when the hand on your leg made the final move up and warm fingers brushed the space where your thigh met your pelvis. Maybe it was the alcohol again, or maybe you were just tired of being the centre of all the guilt today, but you decided to finally indulge yourself, leaving the consequences for later.

You were basically dying with anticipation, Tyler was still teasing the same spot and you desperately wished for his fingers to move a few inches and finally touch your core. You shifted your hips subtly on the couch, trying to send him the message.

Your mission proved successful when warm fingers finally touched between your legs, gently brushing against your folds and sliding down through the wetness that gathered there after all the teasing.

You heard Tyler gasp slightly next to you.

You turned your eyes to him, hoping to find him looking back at you, but you got the same stoic expression as before. God, he must be trying so hard to act like nothing is going on.

You decided to play along with his game and turned your eyes back to the screen, only for them to involuntarily close with pleasure when Tyler changed his light touch on your folds to his fingers finally fully bathing in the wetness that was between them.

Your head fell back against the couch, trying to breathe it out, but even the slightest touch on your flesh sent a powerful wave of pleasure through you.

You felt yourself completely giving in, spreading your legs even more. You were anchored in the moment, in the beautiful pleasure of Tyler´s fingers sliding up to your clit and rubbing in small circles there. The movie on the screen was forgotten and the noises around you felt like you were hearing them underwater.

Until you hear a loud gasp.

One that wasn´t Tyler´s.

It made you snap back into reality, only to find Josh with his head turned towards you, mouth hanging open and shock visible on his features.

Before any guilty thought could cross your mind though, you heard him whine almost desperately and his eyes were pinned on Tyler's hand under your dress.

His hand, that never stopped the movement.

You looked up at Tyler and saw him looking at Josh with a challenging expression. Josh whined again, shifting closer to Tyler, turning to his side so that he could watch openly. He looked like a needy puppy in heat, clinging to Tyler´s free arm and biting his lower lip almost aggressively.

Tyler´s fingers moved from your clit back down through your wetness again, making you whine softly in turn.

"Come here Joshie," he patted his lap with his free arm.

Josh did as he was told, straddling Tylers hips in quick succession.

To your disappointment, Tyler´s hand disappeared from between your legs as he brought it up, level to his face, to observe it. He spread his fingers, watching the juice that stuck to them and both of them inhaled sharply.

"Do you want a taste, Josh?" he asked and before he even finished the sentence, Josh was already greedily opening his mouth for Tyler to stick his fingers into it. He pushed them in with a slight force, Josh closing his mouth and working his tongue over them. ¨

"That's it, baby, lick them clean."

Josh moaned around his fingers as if he was tasting the best flavor of his life and then he whined disappointedly when Tyler pulled them out and threaded them through Josh's hair, tugging his face towards him.

"Come here, let me taste her too," he murmured before capturing Josh in a heated kiss.

You watched the scene in utter amazement, your core throbbing even more now after watching this interaction.

"Oh my god," you moaned out the words softly. It was out of your mouth quicker than you even acknowledged them forming in your head and it made Tyler pull out of the kiss and turn his heated look towards you. You felt yet another wave of heat between your legs just from the way he was looking at you.

"Yeah?" he asked breathlessly as he took in your expression and let his gaze follow down where his hand had been just a moment ago, licking his lips.

"She tastes so good, doesn´t she Josh?," he turned his gaze back to the boy who currently had both arms around Tyler´s neck, biting his lip in anticipation and nodding vehemently. Tyler reached out with his hand again, letting his thumb fall on Josh's lower lip, tugging it down slightly and then hooking it under his bottom teeth, forcing his way inside his mouth.

"Would you like to get more?"

Josh moaned with his mouth full and nodded excitedly again. It was shortly followed by your own whine, when you imagined the boy down between your legs.

"Well it seems she wants you to," he said to Josh before addressing you. "Do you want that? Do you want Josh to make you feel good?

You nodded with your mouth slightly open, which didn't seem to be enough for Tyler.

"Use your words, princess," he said in an authoritative tone that made you press your legs together with need, hoping to get some kind of friction. That action didn´t go unnoticed by him, but he was still waiting for you to say what you wanted.

"Please," you said in a low whine.

It was enough for Tyler to pat Josh's thigh and say "Cmon then, on your knees, pup,"

Josh's eyes widened excitedly as he slid down the couch and onto his knees in front of you. It was just a few hours ago when you first admired his beauty, but you were absolutely not ready for this sight. His eyes were stuck between your legs, where the skirt of the dress was barely covering your glistening pussy. He licked his lips impatiently and looked up to Tyler, obviously waiting to tell him what to do.

So it was like that. No wonder. Tyler´s authority was always the main reason why you were so smitten with him. And it seemed that so was Josh.

You were surprised though, to find Tyler´s attention on you instead of Josh.

He reached out his left hand, gently sliding it across your cheek and then down to your lips, brushing over them slightly. "Princess, whatever happens here, you can always back out, you can always tell us to stop, okay? Josh didn't lie to you when he said we both like you," his eyes scanned your face for any sort of negative reaction. He was checking in.

"The important question now is... Do you want us? Both of us?"

There was a heaviness and hope in his tone. He held your gaze as he waited for your answer, his thumb switching from your lips to your cheek.

As if you moaning out for them just a minute ago wasn´t enough of a confirmation.

"Yes," you answered simply with confidence.

It was all Tyler needed to slide his hand from your lips down to your throat, squeezing experimentally and saying "Well then spread your beautiful legs again so Joshua can get between them."

The movement of your legs was almost automatic and you heard Josh's little gasp as it finally lifted up the dress enough to uncover your needy pussy.

The low whine from your throat as Tyler squeezed it was automatic as well. His face flushed with a knowing smile and he leaned towards you.

"Josh, you know what to do," he addressed the boy before leaning even closer to you, "I'm just gonna kiss you first."

He used his hand on your neck to pull you the last few inches before your lips met in a kiss. The first one was soft, almost testing the unknown territory, but then his hand tightened on the back of your neck and he deepened the kiss, his tongue demanding entrance, which you gladly granted him.

You moaned into the kiss when you felt Josh's hands on your knees, holding them open and then another pair of lips on your inner thigh, followed by a wetness of a tongue.

Without breaking the kiss, you shifted your hips once again, to make yourself more comfortable and to offer Josh an easier access from down there. He understood and eagerly moved his head higher before it disappeared under the skirt of your dress.

A hot breath at first, then an experimental lick and then he was all in your pussy, tongue lapping at your wetness, sliding up to your bundle of nerves, which finally made you break the kiss with Tyler, throw your head back against the couch and moan out loudly.

"Ooohh, god."

Tyler took that opportunity to kiss down your jaw and to your neck and you didn´t know which sensation made you feel better.

He continued down to your collar bones, until he was met with the fabric of your dress and then he went back up, biting lightly near your shoulder. When you gasped at that, he allowed himself to bite a bit more firmly, then soothed the area with his tongue and lifted his head to admire the result.

Josh on the other hand was very gentle with his mouth, flicking the tip of his tongue against your clit over and over tirelessly.

"Ohhh," you sighed loudly, closing your eyes and completely relaxing on the couch, allowing yourself to enjoy the attention.

Meanwhile, Tyler leaned his right hand against the couch, watching you and then he used his other hand to trace soft lines across your skin with the tips of his fingers. First he followed the hem of your dress from your shoulder, then down between your decolt and back up again, then he slid over the thin fabric of your dress, down to your breast, inhaling through his nose when he realized you were not wearing a bra and immediately continued the movement towards your hardened nipple.

He circled the sensitive bud, then ghosted his fingers over it, watching you take in a deep breath. Then he used a bit more pressure, making your chest move on its own, up towards his hand. He squeezed it lightly between his fingers with a satisfied hum.

"Hmm, so responsive," he said as he took your whole breast into his hand, squeezing tightly and reattached his lips to your uncovered neck.

He gave your other nipple similar treatment as he kept kissing your sensitive neck and you were becoming more and more restless against the two of them.

At some point, your right hand found its way into Josh's hair, who was still patiently working down between your legs, eating you out enthusiastically and you felt him moan against you when you gave an experimental tug.

Tyler noticed as well and encouraged you to do it again with a sweet "Oh yeah, he likes when you do that."

When Josh's sweet licks and Tylers endless teasing of your breasts became too much and too little at the same time, you kind of lost control over yourself and you tugged on Josh's hair hard and simultaneously grounded your hips against his face, searching for more pressure.

You felt his nose bury itself deep in your pussy, making him let out a loud moan. He pulled away for a second, taking a quick breath before coming back with a new kind of fervor and sticking his tongue between your folds more forcefully.

"Ohh fuck," you choked on a breath and your left hand grabbed on Tyler´s thigh in a desperate search for something to hold on.

You opened your eyes to see him watching you, biting his lower lip but his expression still somehow controlled. Unlike yours.

"Please," you whispered in a shudder.

He put his own hand over yours that was still grabbing on his thigh, squeezing.

"What do you want, hm?" he asked, not expecting you to reply, because he immediately continued. "Do you want more? Do you want Josh's fingers? Or maybe you want something in your mouth as well, hm?"

You felt your hand being moved, guided by his, up towards his crotch until you were met with a hard bulge in his shorts.

He smirked at your desperate whine. "Maybe you want some of this?"

"Yes, fuck, please.. Tyler."

You realized Josh stopped his actions to watch Tyler move your hand over his hard on, following the movement almost hungrily.

"Hmm..Seems like Josh might want some of that too," Tyler smirked, before giving his boy his full attention.

"Cmere," he said and Josh lifted on his knees to lean closer to Tyler, who softly ran a hand through his hair.

"You did so good, baby, do you think you deserve a reward?" he asked in a low voice and Josh nodded quickly with a quiet whine, his gaze falling down to the bulge in Tylers shorts.

"Hmm, so greedy.. Okay, how about you two go ahead to the bedroom and I´ll be with you in a moment."

Josh didn't hesitate and took your hand before you had a chance to react, already tugging you in the direction of their bedroom.

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

You only had a little time to take in the room before Tyler was there as well with two glasses of water. He put them on the nightstand and turned his attention to Josh.

He snapped his fingers, which seemed to be some sort of gesture Josh knew, because he was immediately kneeling at Tyler´s feet, looking up at him with a pleading expression.

Tyler gave him a satisfied nod before turning his gaze to you.

"You get down here too, princess," he said as he flicked his gaze next to Josh.

Though you were caught off guard a little bit, you still wasted no time moving towards him and down to your knees right next to Josh.

"Good girl," he commented shortly and switched his gaze between the two of you, biting his lip, before settling it back on you.

He made a gesture towards his shorts and raised his eyebrows at you.

"Why don´t you help me out of them, princess?"

So you did, indulging yourself a little by teasing your hands slowly from his waist down towards the waistband, tracing along the elastic band, before tugging on it softly and then carefully sliding the shorts down to reveal his hard dick. The whole time you could almost feel Josh dying of anticipation right next to you.

Once they were discarded, Tyler took his cock in his hand, giving a few lazy tugs, watching both of your desperate expressions.

He put his other hand into Josh's locks, before saying "Come on, pup. Show her how I like it."

Josh was immediately up in his space, nuzzling his face against Tyler's cock and inhaling his scent. It seemed almost ritualistic. And you had the privilege to watch.

He mouthed sloppily at the base before giving a long lick from there up to the head, moaning as if it was his own dick he was licking. He repeated that action a few more times, before closing his lips around the tip of Tyler´s dick and moving his tongue into the slit.

That action made Tyler moan out loud.

You realized it was the first time you heard him do that and it was probably the sweetest and most addictive sound you´ve ever heard. It also caused your pussy to give a needy throb and you felt another wet patch of your juices threatening to flow out.

Josh had almost half of Tyler´s cock in his mouth now, bobbing his head on it enthusiastically. You knew the shaft was long enough for him to have to slide it down his throat if he wanted to take it all in and you anticipated the moment fot it to happen.

You didn't have to wait long though, because after a few more slides of Josh's head, you could hear him take in a breath and he went all the way down, until his nose was buried in Tylers pubes.

Tyler let out a guttural moan when Josh did that and you saw him brace himself with one hand against the bed.

Josh was lost in his own universe, absolutely surrendered to Tyler´s cock, switching between giving a few shallow bobs of his head and then taking him fully down the throat, occasionally gagging when Tyler pushed too far. It was a sight that didn't leave you cold and after some time, your hand found its way between your legs, relieving the tension there by rubbing in small circles.

Tyler´s breath was picking up as well and when Josh went to deepthroat him again, he stuffed both hands into his hair and choked on a moan.

"Oh, fuck yeah, that´s it. That's my good boy," Tyler said as he held his head there for a moment, cutting off Josh's airflow.

You let out an involuntary moan at the action and it snapped Tyler back into reality. He let Josh go and turned his attention towards you and to what your hand has been doing between your legs.

"Now who said you could do that?" he asked, holding Josh's head away from his dick so he could scold you.

"Such a needy little pussy, perhaps you need something else to entertain yourself with."

You whined at his words, your hand back beside your body as you waited for his next move.

He pushed Josh's head back slightly and made a tiny step to the side, holding his dick, that was glistening with Josh´s saliva, in his hand as he looked at you expectantly.

"Go on," he said simply when he saw you eying it hungrily.

You whined softly once again and wasted no more time as you shimmied on your knees a tiny bit closer so you could take him comfortably in your mouth. You gave yourself time for a few experimental licks before going for it and putting all of your effort in sucking him off.

Soon Tyler came to realize that Josh wasn´t the only person in the room that could take dick down his throat like a fucking pro and he was moaning out above you loudly.

Unlike Josh though, he gave you more space and wasn't as forceful with holding you down, which made you a little disappointed, but you figured that you didn't ask for it.. . So you slid off of his dick, licking your lips and regaining your breath. You realized how desperate you must look, tears and saliva streaming down your face as you looked pleadingly into his.

"Please, fuck my mouth.. choke me on it, please.."

Tyler bit his lip hard, but still couldn´t help but moan at your begging.

"Fuck... I knew you were a cockslut as soon as I first saw you sucking on that lollipop in our practice room," he threaded his fingers through your hair as he continued. "Josh.... Looks like you might have some competition here," he said as he finally tugged you back towards his shaft.

He went for it with no remorce, sliding his cock back into your mouth and down your throat. He held you there for a second, before thrusting his hips a few times and then giving you a chance to breathe before going back in.

The feeling of him continously sliding into your mouth and his tip breaching into the back of your throat made you absolutely fall apart, pussy leaking with want.

He put both his hands into your hair as he slid all the way in again, this time holding you down forcefully until your body started shaking with the lack of oxygen and fighting the intrusion helplessly. You tried to pull away, choking on his cock while trying to take a breath in, but he held you there for another second, before pushing you off harshly and leaving you gasping for air.

And then he only gave you a few seconds to recover before doing it again.

You fell into a space where his cock was the only thing that existed, letting him use you like you were a cheap toy only made for a good cock sucking. The only thing you managed to recognize were his moans that were growing louder and louder.

Before you could slip under completely though, he was pulling off and away from you.

"Fuck.. such a good girl," he said, looking out of breath and a bit of sweat was breaking out on his skin.

Josh, next to you, watched both of you with mouth hanging open and expression something between hungry and amazed. Tyler looked down at him.

"Look what you did to my puppy," he lifted his foot and brought it towards Josh´s tenting crotch, rubbing carefully along his hard on.

Josh whined loudly and moved his hips into it to increase the pressure. "Oh fuck, please.. Ty," he whined helplessly.

"I think he deserves some attention as well," Tyler said as he took Josh´s hand and lifted him up and then repeating the same action to you.

He frowned softly when he saw your dress, soaked up from saliva.

"Get undressed," he commanded and moved his gaze again, "You too, Joshua."

Both of you slid the only garment off of you in no time and looked at each other almost sheepeshly.

Tyler´s voice breaking your moment, "Get on the bed. Josh sit down against the headbord," then he turned to you, getting into your space, "you on all fours, facing Josh, your back towards me," he closed his hand over your throat, speaking directly against your lips "I want to see that beautifull pussy on display before I fuck you."

If his hand wasn´t holding you by your throat, your legs would´ve probably give up under you and you´d melt down into the floor. You felt your pussy give an excited squeeze at the image of Tyler being inside you and you felt yourself move towards the bed, getting into the position that Tyler requested.

You found yourself almost face to face with Josh. It was more like your face to his abs and if you gazed just a little lower you were met with a very impressive, very hard cock that was already leaking precum and gave a twitch when Josh saw your attention on it.

Tyler enjoyed the view of the two of you, your pussy on full display, glistening with wetness and calling for attention.

You felt the bed dip behind you with Tyler´s weight on it and then there was a hand sliding from you lower back up until it curled around your throat again and Tyler pulled you up to him, your back against his chest.

He spoke into your ear while holding eye contact with Josh, who was biting his lip hard and his face was flushed with want.

"Here´s what´s going to happen," he started talking as he pressed himself against your backside and you could feel his lenght rest between your butt cheeks.

"I am going to let you explore this beautiful body in front of you. Do whatever you want with him, or to him," he said and Josh whined quietly, "and if I see you doing a good job taking care of my boy, I swear I will give my all to take that little pussy of yours apart until you´re dying of pleasure," he finished his sentence with a thrust of his hips, making his still wet cock slide between your ass cheeks as if he was proving a point.

"Is that something you want?," he murmured into your ear as he closed his hand around your throat more tightly.

"Fuck... yes.. please," you moaned out, already out of breath.

Joshs dick twitched again and he swallowed visibly.

"Okay, princess.. why don´t you start with his mouth, he´s been dying to kiss you all night."

Now that Tyler mentioned it, you realized the two of you didn´t have a chance to kiss yet. You moved on your knees closer to Josh, raising your hand to let it slide from his cheek, down to his neck, across his chest and then back up. He was watching you with anticipation, biting his lip softly.

You realized the dynamic between the two of you would be different from Tyler, who was basically in charge. But here you´ve got a free hand and an equally submissive person right in front of you.

"Can I kiss you?" you asked when your hand ended up on his cheek again and he nodded softly.

You leaned in and connected your lips to his, softly brushing them toghether as his hand slid across your waist, pulling you closer.

You "hmmd" softly into the kiss when it deepened and your hands began to slowly explore each other. You slid your hands from his shoulders across his chest, stopping shortly after you brushed over his nipples and he gave you a needy whine into your mouth. You repeated the action, only now you went for his nipples with intention, leaning back in surprise when he moved into your hands and let out a loud "gAhhh."

"Oh yeah, that´s your jackpot," you hear a voice from behind you. You turned around slightly, just to see Tyler half kneeling on the bed and slowly sliding his hand across his shaft.

You almost forgot that he was in the room as you were so absorbed in Josh and his gentle touch.

You went to kiss him again and found it impossible to do when he threw his head back as you pinched his nipples again. Instead you put your lips to his neck, that was now slightly wet from sweat and tasted a little salty. You kissed down his throat, to his collar bones and then you went purposely for his right peck, closing your mouth around his sensitive nipple and gettin another yelp out of him.

You repeated the same treatment on the other side and then looked up at his face, where you were met with a gone expression.

"Please," he begged in a whisper and his cock leaked another bit of precum. "Please touch me."

You leaned in to kiss him again, leaving his abused nipples alone for now and let your hand slide down towards his neglected cock.

After disconnecting your lips you looked down so you could see your fingers glaze over the tip of his dick, collecting the precum that was there and spreading it along your fingers.

"Do whatever you want with him... or to him," went through your head again, which made you raise your hand up to your face and instead of licking the precum yourself as you normally would, you looked expectantly at Josh before he got the clue and opened his mouth and then you fed him your fingers, making him clean them up thoroughly.

Once you were satisfied, you brought you wet fingers back down and finally closed a fist around him.

"Ohhh, God," he said loudly and shuddered, exactly as someone, whose cock was neglected this whole time, would.

Your other hand reached down to fondle his balls, making him buck up into your hand desperately.

sensitive, you thought.

You moved your hand along his lenght almost lazily, bathing your ears in the sounds he was making. You had a clue not to use too much pressure on him if you didn't want this to be over faster then any of you wanted.

You kept the slow pace and bent down to kiss his chest again, purposefully avoiding his nipples even though you felt how much he wanted you to touch these. You gave open-mouthed kisses along his pecks, then down to his toned abs, licking all over them.

As you went lower you ended up watching your hand jerking his cock slowly, up and down, thumb going over the underside of his cock every time you went up and ocassionaly sliding up into his slit, which made him buck up and moan loudly.

"Fuck, fuck... yeah, just like that," he moaned.

You watching from such a close proximity only made your mouth water again. Tyler might´ve been onto something when he called you a cockslut.

Bending down the few inches you gave and experimental lick to the head of his cock.

"Aaagh," Josh moaned and his abs tighttened even more.

You scooted a little futher down the bed to give yourself a better access to his crotch, finding yourself once again on all fours, supporting majority of your weight on your knees, so if Tyler was still watching from behind you, he was gifted with a very inviting sight.

Teasing Josh with just tiny, soft licks here and there and working your hand over him was enough to make him breathe heavily and for tiny drops of sweat to start forming on his body. He was so sensitive and every sound he made went straight to your core.

When you finally slowly enveloped him in your mouth, he gave out the most beautiful sound and you could feel him holding himself back not to buck into the heat.

Your thoughts of how you actually wanted him to do that were broken by the slightest touch ghosting over your thighs and then up towards your butt. You didn't even realize Tyler moved on the bed to seat himself behind you again.

You moaned around Joshes cock when those hands kneaded your ass cheeks and then pulled them apart to reveal even more of your dripping pussy.

"Fuck... so pretty," you heard Tyler comment behind you.

He began kissing and biting all over your bottom and you pulled off of Joshs dick just in time to moan out loud, when he slid his thumb through your wet folds, teasing at your entrance.

"Oh fuck... please," you begged for him to give you more.

He repeated the action, bathing his thumb in your juices and following the wet path up until he lightly brushed your asshole, surprised when you whined and pushed slightly into him.

"Yeah?" he said as he circled around your asshole with more pressure, almost dipping inside but keeping it on the surface. "Fuck.. maybe next time."

Your hand never stopped the movement on Joshs cock, but your face was now burried next to it in his thigh as you were dying with anticipation, waiting for Tyler to quit all this teasing and get inside you already.

"Please... Tyler," you moaned again.

The mattres dipped again as Tyler repositioned himself behind you, he took his cock in his hand and brought the tip close to your pussy, teasing through the folds, gathering the wetness.

"Hmm.. I dunno," Tyler said, trying to sound uncertain, but noone in the room believed it. "Josh.. do you think she deserves it?"

Josh, who was still focused on the pleasure from the movement of your fist around his cock only moaned and nodded his head several times.

"Alright then."

It felt like a spiritual experience. The time slowing down, dragging every last second of Tyler´s cock teasing around your entrance before he finally, finally, breached his way inside your pussy.

He bathed himself in your wet heat with ease due to you being so turned on, pushing all the way in and embracing the moment for a second, before pulling out almost entirely and thrusting in again.

"Oh my god," you moaned with immense pleasure, your hand stilling on Josh for a moment as your whole body went through a powerful shudder.

"Ohhh, so fucking tight, baby," Tyler moaned behind you.

He braced himself with his hands on your hips, grabbing you tightly and delivered a few more slow deep thrusts before setting up an average rhytm and fucking into you repetitevely. The feeling of your pussy being filled over and over after all the teasing was completely euphoric, leaving you in a haze where nothing else but Tyler´s cock inside you existed.

You heard two sets of groans, one gutteral from Tyler and one desperate whine from Josh next to you, who felt kind of forgotten, since you stopped touching him.

Tyler made a quick move and slid one of his hands from your hip up your back and into your hair, tugging your head up from Joshes thigh and guide you face to face with his cock again, implying for you to get your mouth back to work. You moaned pathetically and reattached your lips to Josh´s forgotten member, taking him in your mouth, no teasing around this time.

The sudden attention made Josh yelp and thrust his hips towards your mouth, which made his cock slide deeper and you gagged around him, unprepared, you pussy tightening in the process. Tyler used his hand in your hair to then make you deepthroat Josh again.

Suddenly you felt so helpless, so out of control and so, so, so very turned on. Having both your holes filled with cock, Tyler fucking into you from behind, while controlling your head with his hand in your hair, deciding exactly how deep Josh´s cock is gonna go into your mouth. Both boys filling the room with the most precious sounds of pleasure. Fuck. You were in seventh heaven.

"Such a goog girl," Tyler said as he slowed down a little.

He let go of your hair, closing his hand around your throat instead and tugging up. He pulled you off of Josh and up against his chest, never stopping the movement of his cock inside you. His other arm slid around your waist and the one on your throat fell down to your chest, fingers pinching one of your nipples, making you whine helplessly as he kept fucking into you from behind.

"Fuck, such a tight little pussy, I could fuck you for hours" Tyler said into your neck before he bit the space where your neck met your shoulder.

He raised his gaze to lock eyes with Josh, who was biting his lip at the sight and his hand was closed in a tight circle around his dick, jerking off.

"J-Josh.." Tyler stuttered when your pussy squeezed around him after another pinch to your nipple.

"Fuck, Josh... you look good enough to eat."

You felt Tyler still himself inside you and groan slightly as if he was not able to decide what to do next. To your disappointment, he slid out of you after another moment, pushing you slightly to the side and shuffling on the bed to get closer to Josh.

"Okay, fuck... I have and idea," he gave Josh a few quick kisses while both boys were holding their own cocks in their hands.

"Josh," Tyler ran his hand over Joshes chest, brushing against one of his nipples and teasing him there, causing him to whine out loudly, "are you up for a little bit of workout?" he asked enigmatically and Josh nodded his head immediately.

Then Tyler looked at you, biting his lip. "And you? .... I want you to ride me."

Of course you´re not gonna say no to that...

He pushed Josh away from the centre of the bed, throwing away the pillows as well before lying there himself. Then he looked at you expectedly and you took the hint and straddled his hips, teasing him a few times by sliding your wet pussy over his shaft before lifting yourself on your knees and taking him back inside. You both sighed at the feeling and you began to move your hips in slow circles.

Josh was left next to you, looking mildly confused, not knowing how he himself is going to fit in this equation, but Tyler just smirked at him and signaled with his hands to come closer.

"Cmon Joshie, I´m hungry," was all he said to make Josh whine loudly.

Unlike you, Josh must have know what it ment, because he was already moving himself towards Tyler´s head and lifting on of his knees to....

"Ah-ah-ah," Tyler tssked and patted Josh´s leg to put it back down, "the other way, baby. We want her to still have acces to the goods. And this is when the workout begins"

Now it was you looking a little confused, but it all fit together, when Josh turned around, facing you again, then lifted his other leg to straddle Tyler´s face, while bracing himself by his hands on the headbord behind him so he wouldn´t suffocate Tyler´s face completely.

Oh....OH.

Josh was now on full display, straining cock between his legs, his torso upright and his arms reaching behind him to lift himself up. Meanwhile Tyler´s face kind of dissappeared between Joshs buttcheeks.

"Oh my god," you and Josh moaned silmultaneously when Tyler used his hands to spread Josh´s cheeks apart.

"Oh GOD," Josh said again, when he gave the first tentative lick over his hole.

Tyler shifted his hips to remind you that you stopped moving on his cock and basically instructed you to keep moving without even using his words.

He licked between Joshs cheeks, lapping his tongue over his hole in repetitive motions, which made Josh scrunch his face in pleasure and his dick twitch with every other lick. The sight of this made your pussy squeeze on Tyler´s cock as you worked your hips over him eagerly.

Tyler used his tongue to push past the ring of tight muscle and Josh moaned out pathetically again.

"Fuck Josh, you taste soo good."

Tyler was soon burrying his face deep between Josh´s cheeks, alternating between giving long licks and pushing his tongue inside. Then he even used his finger to tease around his hole, but never gave him the satisfaction of actually slipping it inside his ass. You watched with utter amazement as he made Josh slowly fall apart, not aware that your movements on Tyler´s cock slowed down.

"Yeah, fuck, please.. please..please," Josh was mumbling weakly.

"Josh, wait.. use one of your hands.. ride my face," Tyler said as he pulled his hands away from Josh´s cheeks and put them on your hips instead.

Josh did exactly that, holding one of his butt cheeks apart and using Tyler´s face to pleasure himself. Meanwhile Tyler had enough of your teasingly slow riding and he grabbed both your hips, stopped you mid motion when you were lifted above him and started fucking up into you in a quick rhythm.

"Oh my god, FUCK," you yelled as he fucked you with a new fervor.

You had to brace yourself against his chest, your lower half inclining a little bit forward, which brought you closer to the sight of Tyler´s tongue on Josh´s hole and Josh´s dick twitching a few inches in front of your face. You only thought how easy it would be to close the small gap and take him into your mouth again. Fuck.

It was almost as if Tyler knew what was going on in your head, because for a moment, he let go of one of your hips and pushed it into your hair again, bringing your head forward, towards Josh dick. Once again, he didn't have to talk for you to get the message.

While Tyler went back to fucking you mercilessly, you closed your mouth around Josh, taking him all in in one swift motion, no time for teasing.

Josh, whose hole was still being rimmed by Tyler´s skilled tongue, let go of his butt to put his hand on the back of your head, which made it more difficult for Tyler to have acces, but he knew Josh wouldn't be able to take both of you going at him for long, so he decided to talk instead.

"Yeah, that´s it Joshie, use her mouth, I can feel she is getting close," he said and he reached one hand to slip it between your legs to rub your clit.

Fuck. It was all becoming too much. Tyler´s hand, his dick repeatedly disappearing inside you and Josh´s breaching into the back of your throat. The pleasure was overpowering you, making you slip into a universe where nothing else existed. Just Tyler and Josh using you.

"Hold her there," you heard a muffled sound of Tylers voice, followed by Josh.

"Fuck, I don´t think I can, I´m so close...,"

"Hold her there," Tyler said with more authority and Josh whined but complied, pushing on your head to hold it against his pubes as be burried his cock inside your mouth.

You were running out of oxygen, Tyler´s hand on your clit rubbed a little faster and his thrust didn´t slow down either. You could feel yourself getting closer and closer to the edge.

Josh let you go and you took a few deep breaths.

"Again," Tyler said and continued in the relentless tempo.

Josh did it again, cutting off your airflow and moaning himself.

"Fuck..I´m gonna....I´m gonna come," Josh said before his whole body spasmed and he pulled his dick back a little just for you to feel him come down your throat and then he pushed your head onto him again.

You felt yourself choking on Josh´s cock and it made your pussy squeeze around the dick that was currently ruining you. Tyler´s hand was gripping you so hard you were sure there are going to be marks tomorrow, but you didn´t care. The way his cock slid repeatedly inside you and his skilled fingers rubbed against you clit made everything else fade away.

It only took a few more of Tyler´s thrusts before you fell apart and shook with the most powerful orgasm you´ve ever experienced. Josh´s cock slipping out of your mouth as you screamed out and shook helplessly on Tyler´s dick, who was still fucking into you ruthlessly, chasing his own release.

You fell down on Tyler´s chest, letting him use you for another few moments, before you felt him stiffen under you as he came hard, gripping onto your hips and groaning out loud.

"Fuuuck."

All three of you kind of dropped down on the bed, breathing heavily. Sweaty bodies, ruined hair, each of you gone for a good amount of time. It was probably Tyler who recovered first enough to throw the blankets over you, but you weren't sure, you went under just shortly after...

____________________________________________________________

When you woke up and opened your eyes, you were met with Josh´s face close to you, watching you.

"Hi," he said.

He was smiling softly, locks were still sticking to his forehead just like they did yesterday evening and his eyes reflected the light of the room. He was looking a little bit nervous, but hopeful.

"Hi," you answered, not intending to move away, or move at all, just looking into his eyes silently.

There was something familiar about this situation, it was reminding you of the moment you two had yesterday in the pool, when you were just looking at each other, smiling, swaying in the water... The moment before he dropped the "Tyler and I are dating" bomb on you.

You frowned a little, which made Josh frown as well.

"Are you okay?" he asked.

You nodded lightly.. "Yeah.. I just... Yesterday was kind of... a lot."

"I know.."

Josh lifted his hand and brought it to your face, tracing a featherlight touch across you cheek, which made you close your eyes in content. He was smiling again when you opened them. He repeated the action before taking your own hand that was folder next to your face and bringing it to his lips, kissing it softly.

"We should probably get up, Ty´s making breakfast."

....

You thankfully accepted Josh´s old shirt when you realized you had nothing else to dress into and then followed him to the kitchen. Tyler was already in the process of cooking scrambled eggs and he smiled widely when he spotted the two of you.

"Hi," he turned to Josh and put one hand on his waist before kissing him softly.

Then to your surprise, he repeated the action to you, as if it was the most normal thing to do.

"Hi," you answered back, pulling down the hem of Josh´s shirt nervously, which caught Tyler´s attention immediately.

"Suits you," he said simply and grinned at you.

"Thanks."

You must´ve looked a little uncertain, because Tyler´s smile softened and he looked you in the eyes reassuringly.

"Cmon, we'll eat the breakfast and then we'll talk."

...

When he said talk, you prepared yourself for the harsh reality, for the fairy tale to finally end and for them to thank you for a beautifull night and ask for it to be forgotten and never talked about again. It was fine, really. You already got so much more out of this friendship that you ever expected and the two of them indulging your little crush was just a cherry on top.

Well you didn't prepare yourself for whatever Tyler actually ended up saying.

"Listen," he paused, looking for the right words. "I know that... I know that yesterday things took rather a quick turn of events, but... Josh and I, we really like you. And you might have guessed that we´re not exactly caught up in traditional ways of relationships, so this is....," he looked a little nervous.

"This is us asking you if you would like to be a part of this. A part of us, our world, which ... you kind of already have been for a long time, but.."

"Do you want to ... date us?"

You were probably holding your breath the whole time Tyler talked. Josh was sitting next to him, huge puppy eyes, hopeful, wishing for you to say yes, while you were left absolutely speechless. Tyler was right. Yesterday took a quick turn of events, it went from having a fun time while crushing on Tyler, to having the worst time and having your hopes crushed, all for it to end in the most amazing sex you´ve ever had.

The thing is, even after everything, you still felt somehow ..normal. Like it was always supposed to be this way. Both of them or nothing. You just never though it would go anywhere past being friends.

"Well, shit..," you said when you finally recovered from your thoughts.

"I mean... I have been sort of dating you for a while now, haven't I?," you chuckled and saw Josh visibly relax next to Tyler, who's face light up with a smile.

"So is this you saying yes?," Tyler asked, although he was almost certain what the answer was.

"It is."

Both boys expression broke with beaming smiles, before Tyler raised a finger...

"Fair warning though... In some aspects we´re.... not exactly vanilla."

"Oh," you faked a frown "I almost didn´t notice yesterday Mr. HOLD HER THERE"

Tyler even had the audacity to blush before speaking "Yeaah, sorry about that, I guess I got a little car..."

"Oh shush," you interrupted him, "I asked for it. And it did make me come, so...

"Well then, princess, you´re in for a ride...."